Skip to main content

Using PixInsight for photometry?

9 posts / 0 new
Last post
LMN
Using PixInsight for photometry?

Hi!

I'm new to observing variable stars with a DSLR. My situation is that I use a Celestron C8 with a DSLR for deep-sky imaging, and my idea was to use the same setup for observations of variable stars. So I run into the question of appropriate software. Now, I use PixInsight for all my image processing (calibrating, stacking, post-processing) - so that is a piece of software quite well known to me. I also know that there are some photometry capabilities there - but not how useful they could be for this purpose.

So my question: is there anyone who knows if PixInsight is useful at all for this, and if so, how do I go about using it for this purpose?

Best,

Magnus Larsson

SFS
PixInsight

According to http://pixinsight.com/performance/ the capability to do CCD photometry is being added; there is no mention of DSLR photometry. That would imply that the software is presently incapable of being used for photometry.

You might bear in mind that the processing protocol for photometry is very different from that used for ordinary imaging, so your prior experience needs to be augmented considerably.  For that reason, it would probably be a mistake to weight your knowledge of PixInsight too heavily if you want to do photometry.

JBD
JBD's picture
PixInsight for photometry - Why not!

Hi!
Can I suggest to read this manual?
https://www.aavso.org/dslr-observing-manual

The base is in the treatment, it's necessary to do a "de-bayerisation" in order to be able to use the spectrum "V" exclusively. PixInsight also allows this function, like AIP4Win but mainly with MaximDL.

But for the treatment of photometry, however, I believe that PixInsight does not have functions compatible with AAVSO either reference stars and compatible reports. Nothing is mentioned in PixInsight forums...  But you can ask it!  (https://pixinsight.com/contact/index.html)

Normaly, for photometry treatement compatible with AAVSO, you must use MaximDL or AIP4Win. 
These are paid programs, but I've heard rumors that AsroimageJ software may soon also have these AAVSO-compatible features and the AAVSO's report.
But maybe I'm wrong!

JBD

Tonisee
Photometry without MaximDL

Hello,  

IMHO there are two separate topics to discuss - debayering of DSLR images and correct measurement procedure for e.g. aperture photometry. There are numerous tools that can debayer RAW files and several free/open source programs to do high-quality  photometry. For example:

http://c-munipack.sourceforge.net

http://www.aperturephotometry.org

I have used AstroImageJ, too, but it seems to me to be a bit too specialized for exoplanet measurements. Of course, there are plenty of cases when the same procedure fits perfectly for stars as well (but not always). 

Now, for me, creating a report for AAVSO is plain spreadsheet business - if you have all the data measured and in CSV or similar format, it is easy to convert it into AAVSO format.

By the way, it seems, that there are aperture photometry scripts for Pixinsight, too. 

Tõnis 

LMN
Hi!

Hi!

Yes, Im asking about the aperture photometry, not the debayering or calibration of the images. I know there is some tools in PI, but I can't easily get my head around it - so wondered here, of someone here knew about it. All since it is a tool that I already have, rathern than needing to get to know another one. But if it is not used, I guess that answers my question...:) as a newbie, my interest is not to do something new, but to familarize myself with the process.

 

Magnus

 

Eric Dose
Eric Dose's picture
PixInsight is designed to

PixInsight is designed to enhance astrophotographs, and the math it employs to do that is quite beautiful.

But it presents problems for photometry. Its toolset for handling linear-domain transforms (as are strictly needed for photometry) is shallow. It forces pixel responses to a 0-1 scale on loading FITS files, and you can't easily undo that. It has (or had) catalog precision problems, and the version I used 1.5 years ago was quite hopeless in handling and using plate solution data.

In short, I worked very hard on using it for photometry for about a month but then gave up. I think we're just not their market.

WGR
WGR's picture
VPHOT for photometry

A a long time CCD observer with AAVSO, I suggest VPHOT, which is supported by AAVSO and is free with membership.  It has so many features that make it the best for doing photometry in my opinion.  It gives lots of diagnostic plots and values that can be used to optimize your results.  Give it a look.  There is nothing better in my optinion.

 

Gary

Ed Wiley_WEY
Ed Wiley_WEY's picture
Second VPhot

I completely agree with Gary. Once you try VPhot you will like it, . But... you still need software to calibrate the images and hopefully stamp the RA and Dec into the Fits header. I have used a variety of different programs to do that, just avoid non-linear processing.

Question: Does VPhot do DSLR images (once properly reduced)? I am a CCD observer and not a DSLR observer.

Ed

RGN
VPhot

I completely agree with both Gary and Ed. In my opinion Vphot is probably the best software for photometry. It plates solves your images and can transform your magnitudes into the standard system automatically, even with ensemble photometry (providing you have previously determined your transformation coefficients). I generally calibrate my images with Maxim DL, then upload them into Vphot and use this software for the photometry.

Gianluca

 

Log in to post comments
AAVSO 49 Bay State Rd. Cambridge, MA 02138 aavso@aavso.org 617-354-0484