Skip to main content

GRB in M31?

2 posts / 0 new
Last post
jrsquid3's picture
GRB in M31?

Anyone looking at this?    I have cloudy skies in NY...



NUMBER: 16332
SUBJECT: Swift detection of a bright X-ray source in M31
DATE: 14/05/27 22:15:08 GMT
FROM: Scott Barthelmy at NASA/GSFC <>

S. D. Barthelmy (GSFC), W. H. Baumgartner (GSFC/UMBC),
S. B. Cenko (GSFC), V. D'Elia (ASDC), D. Malesani (DARK/NBI),
V. Mangano (PSU), F. E. Marshall (NASA/GSFC) and
B. Sbarufatti (INAF-OAB/PSU) report on behalf of the Swift Team:

At 21:24:27 UT, the Swift Burst Alert Telescope (BAT) triggered and
located a source in M31 (NGC224) (trigger=600114). Swift slewed immediately
to the target. The BAT on-board calculated location is 
RA, Dec 10.402, +41.556, which is 

RA(J2000) = 00h 41m 37s
Dec(J2000) = +41d 33' 23"

with an uncertainty of 3 arcmin (radius, 90% containment, including 
systematic uncertainty). This is an image trigger of 64 second duration,
with significance 6.18 sigma, which is lower than typical blind detection 
significance. The BAT light curve does not show obvious structure, which 
is typical for image triggers.

The XRT began observing the field at 21:27:05.4 UT, 157.5 seconds after
the BAT trigger. Using promptly downlinked data we find an X-ray source
with an enhanced position: RA, Dec 10.4292, 41.5734 which is equivalent to:

RA(J2000) = 00h 41m 43.02s
Dec(J2000) = +41d 34' 24.3"

with an uncertainty of 2.9 arcseconds (radius, 90% containment). This
location is 96 arcseconds from the BAT onboard position, within the BAT
error circle. The XRT position may be improved as
more data are received; the latest position is available at This position is 4.0 arcseconds from that
of a known X-ray source: 3XMM J004143.0+413420 in the XMM-NEWTON XMMSSC

A power-law fit to a spectrum formed from promptly downlinked event
data gives a column density consistent with the Galactic value of 1.81
x 10^21 cm^-2 (Willingale et al. 2013).

The associated source in the 3rd XMM catalog has a spectrum and variability
which is consistent with a low-mass X-ray binary (Stiele 2010). However,
the target is also spatially consistent with a globular cluster FMZ2005-7 of M31. 
There may be multiple X-ray binaries within the same globular cluster.

The XRT count rate is approximately 30 counts per second. Assuming a typical
conversion factor to flux, the 0.3-10 keV flux is approximately 1e-9 erg/cm2/s
(uncertain to a factor of 2x). At the distance of Andromeda, this would be a
luminosity of 7e40 erg/s (uncertain to the same factor).

This luminosity is clearly super-Eddington for a ~solar mass compact object,
so either the object is of ULX class, or it is significantly beamed.

UVOT took a finding chart exposure of 150 seconds with the White filter
starting 162 seconds after the BAT trigger. UVOT detects a 16.9 mag source
at the position

RA (J2000) = 00:41:43.10 = 10.42957
Dec(J2000) =+41:34:20.4 = 41.57232

with a 90% confidence error radius of 0.61 arc sec. 
This position is 4 arc seconds from the center of the XRT error circle
and consistent with the position of the globular cluster. 
No correction has been made for the expected extinction corresponding to E(B-V) of 0.06.




jrsquid3's picture


I jumped on it too soon....


NUMBER: 16336
SUBJECT: Swift trigger 600114 is not an outbursting X-ray source
DATE: 14/05/28 07:57:12 GMT
FROM: Kim Page at U.of Leicester <>

K.L. Page, P.A. Evans (U. Leicester), D.N. Burrows (PSU), V. D'Elia
(ASDC) and A. Maselli (INAF-IASFPA) report on behalf of the Swift-XRT

We have re-analysed the prompt XRT data on Swift trigger 600114 (GCN Circ.
16332), taking advantage of the event data.

The initial count rate given in GCN Circ. 16332 was based on raw data from
the full field of view, without X-ray event detection, and therefore may
have been affected by other sources in M31, as well as background hot
pixels. Analysis of the event data (not fully available at the time of the
initial circular) shows the count rate of the X-ray source identified in
GCN Circ. 16332 to have been 0.065 +/- 0.012 count s^-1, consistent with
the previous observations of this source [see the 1SXPS catalogue (Evans
et al. 2014):].

We therefore do not believe this source to be in outburst. Instead, it was
a serendipitous constant source in the field of view of a BAT subthreshold

This circular is an official product of the Swift-XRT team.

Log in to post comments
AAVSO 49 Bay State Rd. Cambridge, MA 02138 617-354-0484