Second Istanbul
Amateur Astronomy Symposium
By Gamze Menali
As some of you may remember, David Levy, Wendee Levy, and I attended the
First Istanbul Amateur Astronomy Symposium that was organized in Istanbul, Turkey
(June 25-26 2005), and dedicated to our beloved Janet.
This year, the same university (Istanbul Kultur University) that organized
the first symposium held the second amateur astronomy symposium again in
Istanbul. Arne and I attended as invited speakers, and Linda, Arne, Dick
Parker from Connecticut, and my dear husband Haldun were the guests of honor
also! It was fun!
This year, as part of the whole event, there was a telescope mirror making
workshop also (a first in the country's history, so it was a huge deal for
the participants and for the university also). Haldun and Dick Parker, an amateur astronomer from Connecticut,
were the instructors of the workshop and need I say that it was a great success?
There was so much interest that 150 people applied for a workshop that was
limited to 25 per our instructors' request. They held a mini observing
session at the end of the 5-day workshop. Pictures from the event may be seen here
The symposium followed the workshop (July 15-17). In this article, I'd like
to share my impressions of the symposium with you. Since I always want to
take you all with me whenever I go to places and since that is virtually
impossible, I can at least bring some memories back to you through an
article.
Let's get going... I was the session chair for the opening session and
interestingly my talk was under my chairmanship! So I got to be my own
boss and got to watch my own time, etc. It was as liberating as it was
interesting. I
chose my talk to be rather simple and fun to attract as many people as
possible since there were spouses, kids, etc. attending the session. I talked
about the "Golden Rules" pertaining to star parties: use a red light, don't
leave trash behind you, make sure to benefit from all the telescopes, ask
first before touching any telescope, don't miss the rising of Milky Way, etc.
Mostly common sense, however, since they have only one major star party going
over there, the concept was kind of new to them and I heard afterwards that
my
talk was much appreciated, so it was right on the spot and I was pleased to
have heard that.
 |
 |
 |
| The Amateur Telescope Mirror Making Workshop attracted many people |
Two home made telescopes. LEFT one by Ugur Ikizler, an amateur mirror maker from Bursa, Turkey and RIGHT one by Haldun Menali
| Meeting attendees at a cocktail hour on the roof, at the end of the first day. |
Arne's talk was well received also. Arne had the brilliant idea of having me
translate his slides into Turkish, so that the Turkish would be in the
background for people to read while he was giving his talk in English rather
than translating back and forth. It worked out beautifully. The role of
amateur participation in modern science/astronomy was a great topic to
capture
the attention of the specific crowd that was there.
Prof. Dursun Kocer (the organizer) and I went to the airport to meet Arne and
Linda and took them to the university to show them the workshop room, etc.
Then we took them to their hotel to give them a little break. At the end of
Arne and Linda's arrival day, there was a dinner on the roof of the
university's building where we could mix and mingle, meet and greet.
At the end of the first day of the symposium, there was a cocktail party.
Although we had planned to go out for kebabs for dinner... what they called
a cocktail party was almost a decent dinner, so we were full by the end of
it! Instead we opted for Starbucks! YES... There is Starbucks in Istanbul,
but for whatever reason the coffee never tasted the same to me. However, I
decided not to act so spoiled and be grateful for what I had. It actually
wasn't too bad. Better than nothing at all! The iced coffee as we know it
is "Coffee Americano" over there! So if you are in the mood for iced coffee,
ask for "Coffee Americano", otherwise you will get something that is kind of
similar to iced latte that just wouldn't taste the same as iced black coffee!
 |
 |
 |
| Can Arne speak Turkish?! |
Meeting attendees |
Dick Parker, myself, Arne, Linda, and my mom enjoy a visit to Starbucks |
To give you a rough idea of the paper topics.. There were some that were
written for professional astronomers, some very specific, some quite
informative (perhaps more than it was necessary), a few laid back and funny,
all informative and a very diverse selection of articles. Various amateur
astronomy clubs, some new, some established, some from the universities'
student clubs, talked about their clubs and activities. There were papers
about amateur telescope making, amateur rocket making, serious cosmology,
radio astronomy, spectroscopy, CCD, visual observing. One of our members,
Yenal Ogmen, gave an excellent paper about how to make variable star
observations and how to submit them to AAVSO. There was one paper about
solar observing and SIDs, and it was clear to us from that paper that the
author had received a lot of guidance, help, and support from the AAVSO's late
Cap Hossfield. There was a paper about the Space Camp in Turkey. I was
very surprised and pleased to have realized that there was one there.
There apparently are only four international space camps and one of them is
in Izmir (Smyrna), Turkey. So it was great to get an update about what is
going on there. They do a great job indeed.
Two years ago it was only my paper that talked about AAVSO and its wonderful
guidance and influence. This year there were four papers that directly talked
about AAVSO and many more that mentioned us and gave us credit. I thought
that
was pretty good. Slowly but surely we are spreading the AAVSO fever!
 |
 |
 |
| Beginning of the loooong boat ride down the Bosphorus! |
A view of Rumeli Castle from the boat. The castle was built in 1452. |
The beautiful Bosphorus bridge. That's Europe on the left and Asia on the right. |
At the end of the second day, there was the boat ride down the Bosphorus
heading towards the Black Sea. Arne, Linda, and Dick got on the boat in
Europe
(literally the continent) and they stepped on the Asian side (literally the
continent). The boat ride was as magical and peaceful at times as it was
crazy!
The magic part was related to the sights (the centuries-old forts and
structures, huge Russian ships carrying cargo down the strait, the wonderful
villas by the water, the wealth of the culture, the modern face, the old and
the new - all at the same time), and the crazy part was the loud and I mean
loud music! Everybody was dancing and it was great from the beginning,
however, try to imagine screaming-loud music for the duration of the trip!
We were pretty good at filtering it out and concentrating on the good,
though.
We were admiring the ever-changing colors on the Bosphorus Bridge and trying
to guess what color was going to come next, etc. Overall, I thought it was a
good ride. However I couldn't help but wonder if I was still going to have my
job by the time we returned home to Boston after putting Arne through that!
If
you guys are reading this article now, that means that I am still around...so
far so good.
 |
 |
 |
| Gamze's proposals to Arne for AAVSO's Istanbul branch! |
The night is young (still on the boat!) See what we were up against? |
On the third day, the day Arne and Linda were scheduled to leave, we went to
the conference center for the morning session but we were very casually
dressed. Naturally Arne and Linda were in their travel outfits, shorts and
T-shirts, and I was in my jeans (as opposed to very dressy outfits that I
had on during the previous two days) and my hair was all over the place
since I was having a terrible hair day. Guess what?? The president of the
university, Prof. Tamer Kocel, walked in to invite us to the stage to give
us some beautiful plaques in recognition of our attendance at their
symposium!!
As you will see from the pictures, we looked like tourists passing by, but
oh well... With no notice, I guess we were in pretty decent shape, if you ask
me. The president thanked us all for our efforts and for being there to make
the symposium even more special, and we thanked him for his generosity and
for
his hospitality.
 |
 |
| The last day of the symposium we were unexpectedly called to the stage and honored with plaques (even though we were in our travel attire!) |
Haldun, myself, Prof. Dr. Ethem Derman, Yenal's wife and Yenal, an AAVSO observer. |
On that day, Prof. Dr. Kocer and I took Arne and Linda to the airport, and
they set sail to new frontiers in their journey of discovering Turkey.
Speaking of the president, I want to talk a bit about him. In Turkey, science
and science projects don't attract much financial support from the
government,
and the private schools and universities usually pour money into other things
like arts and literature, etc. Istanbul Kultur University
(http://www.iku.edu.tr/) is one of the few of its kind, if not the only one
so far, that has been incredibly supportive of science-related activities,
astronomy in particular. Prof. Kocel is not only the person who puts his
signature under every check but he gets personally involved with the
activities. Regardless of his busy schedule, he made time to come down to
attend to paper sessions, to visit the ATM workshop, to chat with the
attendees, and he even treated the attendees to a yummy triple chocolate
cake one day. To this day, I pull my hair and yell at myself for missing
that wonderful opportunity! That day happened to be the one day I wasn't
there and of course this was going to happen...a la Gamze style! But I am
forever grateful to Prof. Dr. Tamer Kocel for his generosity and for his
guidance and his support. Always.
Also, my deepest appreciation goes to Fahamettin Akinguc, the chairman of
the Board of Trustees of Kultur University, for his leadership and his
never-ending support of science, astronomy in particular, to Prof. Dr.
Dursun Kocer for his immense contributions to the world of science and for
being hands-on with every activity throughout, and to Aysegul F. Teker and
Korhan Yelkenci for a superb job well done. Once again, if it weren't for
their involvement and support, I sure wouldn't have had these wonderful
memories to share with you.
Arne and Linda made this trip super special for me. When I saw them coming
through that door at the airport in Istanbul, something that I've known all
along had just been proved once again: that my heart is equally divided into
two and in one lives the Turkish part while in the other right next to it
resides my American half. It is hard to explain with words, however, when I
saw Arne and Linda there at the airport, I knew some place deep in my heart
was truly smiling. Talk about missing people!
I was grateful that Arne took the time with his crazy schedule I know so well
to attend to the symposium. It meant the world to people and the students
over there to have someone they look up to visiting them.
I, as always, will wish that I will be able to take you all with me but since
that won't be happening, I look forward to sharing many more memories with
you in the years to come. Until then, stay healthy and happy.
Meeting notes from Arne Henden
 |
| Arne Henden's talk at the Istanbul Conference was well-received |
I was excited to be invited to Istanbul for the 2nd Annual Amateur Astronomy
Symposium. Gamze was a great resource, coming with Dursun to the airport
to pick Linda and I up, helping with translations and giving us advice
about the city and travelling.
When we arrived on Saturday, the last day of the mirror-making workshop,
we went immediately to the University to see the progress made by the
participants. It was really fun to see so many mirrors nearly finished
and a long line of people waiting to test their mirrors after polishing.
Dick continued working with the workshop folks all through the scientific
paper sessions, with about half of the mirrors deemed "good enough" by
the end - a very good record. Haldun was a whirlwind of activity,
a driving force for both the mirror-making workshop and the scientific
paper session.
The scientific papers were good, with lots of ideas and a broad range
of projects. As Gamze mentioned, they ranged from model rocketry to
light pollution mitigation to theoretical modelling. The sessions were
well attended, with plans to get even more people attending the next
Symposium. While most papers were given in Turkish, PowerPoint slides
tend to be universal and easy to understand. Most of the students were
shy to speak in English at informal settings later, but once drawn
out of their shells, obviously knew far more English than I did Turkish!
Turkey is a country that is just starting to become active in amateur
astronomy. There are clubs throughout the country, but few telescopes
or CCD cameras. All commercial equipment is expensive on the typical
limited income of Turkey's residents. The 8-inch mirrors created
in the workshop will form the basis for many visual observing programs
throughout the country. Probably the biggest impediment for amateur
astronomy in Turkey is light pollution. Most of the people live in
large urban areas like Istanbul, where you can barely make out the
brightest stars. However, internet is everywhere, computers are
available, and the amateurs I met were uniformly enthusiastic, interested
in variable stars, and willing to work to become better observers.
As a mediterranean country, Turkey has lots of clear weather and a good
geographic location - we can use more of their observers in our programs.
If you get a chance to visit, I highly recommend it. Not only are
the people friendly, but the countryside is unique and the long
history means there are archeological sites present from almost every
civilization.
A special thank you to Haldun Menali for providing all of the pictures for this article.