|
|
|
|
Variable Star Of The Month
June, 2000: SS Cygni
"The stars that have most glory, have no rest." -Samuel Daniel in History of the
Civil War Over a Century of Observations
 | | Click on the above image to view the long-term light curve of SS Cyg. | Since its
discovery in 1896 by Louisa D. Wells of the Harvard College Observatory, SS Cygni has undoubtedly been one
of the most observed variable stars in the night sky. In the past century of notoriety, not a single
outburst of SS Cyg has been missed. In this time, nearly 220,000 observations submitted by AAVSO observers
across the globe have contributed to the monitoring of some 800 outbursts. Being the brightest of the stars
of its dwarf nova class, there is no doubt that SS Cyg is a favorite of many observers.
SS Cygni Takes the Stage The discovery "of a
(variable) star in the constellation of Cygnus" was announced in Harvard College Observatory Circular
No. 12 (November 12, 1896) by E.C. Pickering. A photographic range of 7.2 to 11.2, and a period of 40 days
was given, which Mr. Pickering noted as "an unusually large range for a variable having so short a period."
This new variable was assigned the name SS Cyg in 1897; a name that has become well known and revered in the
astronomical community. The 1896 discovery of SS Cyg proved to be only the second star of the dwarf nova
type, with U Gem being the first of the class with its discovery in 1855. (In stark contrast, today there
are currently over 375 known dwarf novae.) In the Annual Report of the Director of Harvard College
Observatory for the year ending September 30, 1896, Mr. Pickering states that "Five new variables have been
found by Miss L.D. Wells from a comparison of chart plates. The most important of these is W Delphini, a
star of Algol class..." (Hazen, 1997). Clearly SS Cyg's rise to fame was not predicted. Getting to Know SS Cygni  |  | | SS Cygni in its low and high states, as taken with the Stamford Observatory 22-inch
Maksutov telescope at f/3.7. Images courtesy of Charles Scovil. | With many dilligent
observers watching SS Cyg for well over a century, the tireless behavior of the variable has been well
observed in the visual portion of the spectrum. SS Cyg typically remains in quiescence about 75% of the
time. From this low state, the star then begins to brighten without warning, and reaches maximum light in
just a day or so. The light curve of SS Cyg then shows a distribution of alternating wide and
narrow outbursts, which bear no specific cyclic pattern. Based on the AAVSO International Database, SS
Cyg has a visual range of 12.2 at minimum to 8.3 at maximum. Recurrence can be expected every 4-10 weeks,
with a duration of 1-2 weeks. SS Cyg, like all other cataclymic variables, consists of a close binary
system. One of the components is a red dwarf-type star, cooler than our Sun, while the other is a white
dwarf. Studies suggest that the stars in the SS Cyg system are separated (from surface to surface) by "only"
100,000 miles or less. In fact, the stars are so close that they complete their orbital revolution in
slightly over 6 1/2 hours! Astronomically speaking, SS Cyg is also fairly close by, being a distance of 90
to 100 light years from its Earth-bound admirers (Burnham, 1978). The inclination of the system has been
calculated to be about 50 degrees, yielding a respective component mass of Mwd = 0.60 solar mass
and Mms = 0.40 solar mass (Honey, et al., 1989). SS Cyg's bright appearance, frequent
outbursts, and location in the sky seem to be almost a recipe for a successful variable star! Observing SS Cygni This enchanting variable is located in
the constellation of Cygnus the Swan. The Cygnus constellation finder chart will help the first time
observer locate the section of the sky in which SS Cyg can be found. The "b", "c", "d", and "e" scale charts (available in regular and reversed chart
format) may then be used to make variable star estimates. For observers with small telescopes, this is a
rewarding variable to watch since its range can be easily covered with such equipment. This star is cetainly
a favorite of northern observers, especially those who find Cygnus to be a circumpolar constellation.
...Then up rose SS Cygni--he was bright and white and high-- Standing full 8.2
on the rostum of the sky. As the Dean of stellar sages he was far above the others, And his beam
seemed to break as he addressed his weaker brothers: "We might as well give up, for whether hiding high
or low, We cannot escape the vigils of the AAVSO"...
-David Pickering, May 8,
1920 | Since SS Cyg's behavior is somewhat unpredictable, one observation per clear night
is desired. However, the star should be observed several times a night when active, with the time noted to
the minute. If you are unsure of the star's current activity, the AAVSO
Quick Look files (which may now be access by the AAVSO Light Curve Generator) and the AAVSO News Flash will help to determine SS Cyg's present status.
The Outbursts SS Cygni is a cataclysmic variable star, of the dwarf nova class. Such variables are comprised of a close binary system with a white dwarf primary
star and a red dwarf secondary star, as mentioned above. Due to the evolution of the system, the main
sequence star loses matter which is streamed in the direction of the primary, forming an accretion disk
around the white dwarf star. The observed outbursts are believed to be the result of processes that arise in
the hydrogen-rich disk. Whether the activity is the result of a sudden transfer of mass from the secondary
to the primary (as postulated in the mass-transfer burst model), or if it is the product of
instabilities within the disk (as prescribed by the disk-instability model) remains to be determined.
(For a further review of this topic, see VSOTM SU
UMa and RS Oph and references therein.) During
this time, typical dwarf novae rise by 2-6 magnitudes on a timescale of 10-1000 days. One
of the signifying features of dwarf nova light curves is that each outburst does not necessarily look like
the others. That is, the shape of the outburst may change from cycle to cycle. A look at SS Cyg's light
curve reveals ever-changing intervals of wide and narrow outbursts, of about 18 and 8-day durations,
respectively. In addition, we also see the occasional anomalous outburst, which are typically rare in
frequency, wide and symmetrical in shape, and occur with a slow rise rate. Although the star has typically
displayed this changing outburst characteristic since its discovery, SS Cyg underwent a period of
"confusion" between 1907 and 1908 when it ceased to exhibit its normal outburst behavior and only underwent
minor fluctuations. After this time, such behavior has not been observed again.  | | "SS Cygni still remains one of the greatest enigmas in variable star astronomy, and
continuous observations throughout its entire light curve are essential to the final solution of the problem
presented." -Leon Campbell, Annals of Harvard College Observatory Volume 90, No. 3. |
After an extensive study of SS Cygni's light curve, Leon Campbell (1934) concluded that the
outbursts could be classified by a letter sequence depending on their rise and decay times: class A with a
rapid rise to maximum; class B with a slightly slower rise; class C with a moderate rise; and class D with
an exceedingly slow rise. The C and D classifications are referred to as anomalous in comparison with the
rapidly rising of the A and B types. The A and B outbursts, however, are then classified into wide and
narrow in nature. Further investigation showed the A class as the leader with 64% of the outbursts being of
this type, B with 9%, C with 18%, and D with 9%. A later study by Bath and van Paradijs (1983) refined the
definitions of classes such that type A outbursts generally begin from a quiescent state of visual magnitude
of 11.9 +/- 0.12, while the others brighten from 11.64 +/- 0.30. Statistical studies of SS Cygni's light
curve over the years have revelaed numerous correlations (Sterne and Campbell, 1934; Bath and van Paradijs,
1983), one of which being the preference of wide and narrow outbursts occurring in an alternating pattern.
An investigation of the long-term behavior of SS Cyg was carried out by Cannizzo and Mattei in 1992
concerning the outburst type. In this publication, an outburst is said to occur when the variable exceeds a
visual magnitude of 10. The outbursts are then separated by timescale according to long, or wide, outbursts
(denoted by the letter "L") with a duration exceeding 12 days, while the short, or narrow, outbursts
(denoted by the letter "S") consist of less than 12 day duration. A study of the data yielded the most
common sequence as LS (with 134 occurrences), LLS (69), LSSS (14), and LLSS (8). Together these strings
represented 89% of the outburst studied. Cannizzo (1993) has suggested that the determining factor as to
whether an outburst will be a wide or narrow episode depends upon the amount of mass in the disk at the
start of a thermal instability. That is, the narrow outburst may correspond to moderate mass transfer, while
wide outbursts may be inspired by a major mass transfer. For a further review of this subject, see the paper
by Smak listed below.  | | A portion of the SS
Cygni light curve from the AAVSO International Database displaying interchanging bouts of wide and narrow
outbursts. | Thanks to AAVSO
Observers It seems that SS Cyg is always at the forefront of breaking new ground. Its
involvement in the very first AAVSO Alert Notice, published on
June 11, 1974, is no exception.  | | The X-ray flux from
SS Cygni, as detected by the EINSTEIN satellite. | The observational plea sent out worldwide
was an "URGENT REQUEST" for visual observations to assist, the then, forthcoming radio observations for
astronomers at the David Dunlap Observatory. Since that time, SS Cyg has been the subject of 50 Alert
Notices, in which visual observations have been requested of AAVSO observers to correlate with X-ray,
ultraviolet, infrared, and radio observations. Assisted satellites include a various number of NASA and
European Space Agency missions, such as Apollo-Soyuz, HEAO-1, HEAO-2 (EINSTEIN), ANS, Ariel V, IUE, Voyager,
IRAS, EXOSAT, ASCA, ROSAT, HST, EUVE, BEPPOSAX, and RXTE. Why such an intense interest in
multi-wavelength coverage? Theory has suggested that the light we see in the visual portion of the
spectrum during outburst arises from the cooler, outer-most region of the accretion disk. The inner disk,
however, is hotter as a result of the liberated accretion energy, and is the source for ultraviolet
emission. The boundary layer between the accretion disk and the white dwarf is even hotter, and as a result
emits X-ray and extreme-ultraviolet radition. Thus, in order to investigate the properties of the inner
regions of the disk and the boundary layer of SS Cyg, as well as other dwarf nova-type stars, it requires
observations with satellites that have instruments that can observe in high-energy bands. Why choose
SS Cygni for such observations? There are three reasons why SS Cyg is a favored CV for multi-wavelength
obsevations: (1) it is bright, (2) it is nearby, and (3) because of low hydrogen column density, ie, a low
number of hydrogen particle/cm2 between us and SS Cyg. With continued observations throughout
the spectrum, we will be able to learn more about this fascinating variable. Since SS Cyg's outbursts occur
unpredictably, professional astronomers rely of the eyes and instruments of amateur astronomers to help
pinpoint the start of an outburst. Thanks to all the AAVSO observers who have spent countless hours heeding
the call for observations!
SS Cygni Creates a
Stir Target-of-opportunity observations of this and other stars become quite exciting when
trying to predict the activity of a star. In 1996, Dr. Peter Wheatley, of RXTE, and Dr. Chris Mauche, of
EUVE, wished to observe SS Cyg during its October outburst. For this project, both Drs. Wheatley and Mauche
needed to be informed precisely when the star would go into outburst. To obtain this information, they
turned to the AAVSO. As instructed, AAVSO observers took vigil throughout the night. Indication of SS Cyg's
activity was detected by observers in California and Kansas when the variable had achieved a magnitude of
11.5. Later observations of a Hawaiian observer confirmed the activity with a magnitude estimate of 10.9. In
the Director's Report presented in the Journal of the
AAVSO (JAAVSO) Volume 25, Dr. Mattei shares a bit of the excitement that ensued: Dr. Mauche
wrote:
 |
| Cartoon modified by Daniel Costanzo 4/79. |
Your Hawaiian observer, Bill Albrecht, called to say that at JD 2450365.779 SS Cyg
had reached 10.9, so he said he was positive it was going to go up. He went so far as to say that he would
put money on it. So, I called Pete, who'll contact XTE and eventually SAX...Anyway, sounds like we're all
set. I hope Bill is right - maybe he's been drinking too much hard pineapple juice! Dr.
Wheatley wrote the next day: Chris phoned me at 0700 UT with the news from Hawaii. I got
onto XTE and triggered the satellite straightaway. They have an advertised response time of seven hours, so
it's possible we'll get onto SS Cyg with 11 hours of the first observer calling Janet. That would be
great...I was so excited at the news that I fell off my bike on the way to work - and I'm sitting here
covered in cuts and bruises. It's a dangerous business we're engaged in. As a result of
this enthusiastic amateur-professional collaboration, the October 1996 outburst of SS Cyg was observed
simultaneously for 12 days in the visual, ultraviolet, and X-ray band passes. In light of this excitement,
Dr. Mattei will be presenting the results of this unique and important multi-wavelength observing run at the
American Astronomical Society meeting in
Rochester, NY, June 4-8, 2000! Impressed by the success of the project and to provide more
opportunities for amateur astronomers, the director of EUVE granted three day's of observing time of with
EUVE to the AAVSO to use on any star of
choice! Thanks again to AAVSO observers!  | | The narrow October
1996 outburst of SS Cygni provided astronomers with more clues about the nature of dwarf nova outbursts. For
more information about the SS Cyg collaboration, visit RXTE's Greates Hits and EUVE Science
Highlights. | The Excitement
Continues In the summer of 2000, SS Cyg will be observed by the Chandra X-Ray Observatory and EUVE with hopes to learn even more about this
fascinating variable. Be sure to keep an eye out for AAVSO Alert
Notices and AAVSO News Flashes for requested monitorings!
As an interesting sidenote, the AAVSO has a special tie to this satellite. AAVSO member and observer
Gary Emerson worked as a test engineer at
Ball Aerospace on Chandra's Charge Coupled Device (CCD) camera. SS Cygni For Sale  | | Just a few of the stellar gifts available. From left to right: t-shirts displaying the
long-term light curves of Mira, SS Cyg, and Z Cam. | Not only has SS Cyg been a
favorite in the sky, but it has also been the subject of many stellar gifts available for purchase through
the AAVSO over the years. Currently available is a SS Cygni t-shirt. So be sure to replace your old, worn
out t-shirts with our navy blue cotton t-shirt which displays the historical light curve of SS Cyg. To
purchase this and other stellar gifts, be sure to visit our online store! For More Information - AAVSO
Monograph #1: SS Cygni 1896-1985
- AAVSO
Monograph #1, Supplement #1: 1985-1990
- AAVSO
Monograph #1, Supplement #2: 1991-1995
- AAVSO Standard Charts for 2138+43 SS Cygni: "b", "c", "d", and "e" scales are
available in both standard are reversed format.
- Bath, G.T., and van Paradijs, J. "Outburst
Period-Energy Relations in Cataclysmic Novae." Nature, 305, 1983, 33-36.
- Burnham, Robert Jr.
Burnham's Celestial Handbook (3 volumes). New York: Dover, 1978.
- Campbell, L. "The Light
Curve of SS Cygni, 213843." Annals of the Observatory of Harvard College, 90, 1934, 93.
- Cannizzo, John K., and Janet A. Mattei "A Study of the Outbursts in SS Cygni." The Astrophysical
Journal, 505, 1998, 344-351.
- Cannizzo, John K. "The Accretion Disk Limit
Cycle Model: Toward an Understanding of the Long-Term Behavior of SS Cygni." The Astrophysical
Journal, 419, 1993, 318-336.
- Cannizzo, John K., and Janet A. Mattei "On the Long-Term Behavior of
SS Cygni." The Astrophysical Journal, 401, 1992, 642-653.
- Hack, Margherita, and
Constanze la Dous, eds. Cataclysmic Variables and Related Objects. Washington, DC: NASA Scientific
and Technical Information Branch, 1993.
- Hazen, Martha L. "The Centennial of the Discovery of SS
Cygni." Journ. AAVSO, 26, 1997, 59-61.
- Hempelmann, A., and J. Kurths "Dynamics of the Outburst
Series of SS Cygni." Astronomy and Astrophysics, 232, 1990, 356-366.
- Hempelmann,
Alexander, and Jürgen Kurths "Mass Transfer Rate and
Outburst Cycle of SS Cygni." The Astrophysical Journal, 412, 1993, L41-L42.
- Honey, W.B.,
G.T. Bath, P.A. Charles, et al. "Quiescent and Outburst
Photometry of the Dwarf Nova SS Cygni." Monthly Notice of the Royal Astronomical Society, 236,
1989, 727-734.
- Mattei, Janet A. "SS Cygni." Journ. AAVSO, 3.2, 1974, 43-48.
- Mauche,
Christopher W. has webpage where he
gives an excellent review of cataclysmic variables. Dr. Mauche also has a page devoted to his
publications about SS Cygni and other related topics.
- Smak, J. "Dwarf Nova
Outbursts. II. On the Nature of "Narrow" and "Wide" Outbursts." Acta Astronomica, 49, 1999,
383-389.
- Sterne, T. E., and L. Campbell "Properties of the Light Curve of SS Cygni." Annals of
the Observatory of Harvard College, 90, 1934, 189.
- Szkody, Paula A., and Janet A. Mattei "Analysis of the AAVSO Light
Curves of 21 Dwarf Novae." Publcations of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 96, 1984,
988-995.
- Warner, Brian. Cataclysmic Variable Stars. New York: Cambridge UP, 1995. ISBN
0-521-41231-5.
This month's Variable Star of the Month was prepared by
Kerri Malatesta, AAVSO Technical Assistant.
|